Posted by
grad_1986 on Tuesday, March 03, 2009 1:51:16 PM
Well I haven't done my taxes yet this year (it's a little later than usual for me). Not that I am worried about needing to send more money to the feds this year (I adjusted my W4 last year so I should be OK), it's just the whole process that pains me. Getting out all the documents, installing the software (TurboTax) and spending 3-4 hours in front of my computer agonizing over every question asked by the writers of tool. Then when its all done, agonize over whether I had done everything correct and did my submission actually get recorded at the IRS. UGH! Just thinking about it makes my blood pressure go up!
This past election, a lot of attention was given to the whole issue of paying taxes. Whose rich and whose not. Who pays what and who pays nothing. A lot of statistics where presented to the voters for our consideration. For example, the top 5% of earners in America pay 50% of ALL the taxes to the IRS and 40% of all working Americans pay NOTHING. WOW! Those are some glaring statistics I had never heard of before. What it means is that 5% of all Americans have a large stake in their government and 40% have no stake whatsoever (its all free money to them). To me this is nothing more than class warfare at its worst. On one side we say, "Try as hard as you can to be a success", but then when you become a success its "How dare you be a success! You must have stepped on a lot of little people to get here! Time to pay up!"
Another statistic I found interesting was that the current tax code is 16,000 pages of small type. Too many of us think the tax code is the 100 page 1040 Form document we get around January in the mail. But in reality that is only represents about 0.01% of the actual code. The rest of the tax code is full of "special interest exceptions" and "loop-holes" and other sections only a tax lawyer would come to love. Isn't it time to rid ourselves of this "shackle" of our society? Isn't it time for a FAIR tax? A tax that cannot be "loop-holed"? A tax that gives everyone in America a stake in their government? A tax that will make our businesses more competitive and more efficient? I say it is!
I know I am not the first to suggest a 1% Federal Sales Tax and I know I will not be the last. But we need to keep up the dialogue on this idea until we get heard for there are so MANY benefits to this change. Let me discuss a few of them here
Makes EVERYONE have a stake in their government
Like I mentioned earlier, 40% pay no tax to the IRS. To them, government waste is a non-issue. Why should they care? It's not their money. They didn't pay anything to the Feds. We often talk about the apathy in our voters and the low voter turnout every November. To me that is only a symptom of the real disease that plagues our nation. 40% feel its not their government and what happens in Washington does not impact them very much. That leaves the other 5% who have a LOT a stake in the government and because they have such a large stake pay MILLIONS in dollars to lobbyists and political-action-committees to insure that if they are going to be plunking down BILLIONS in taxes, they better get their money's worth!
Frees up business (especially small business)
Its been said that our country is built on small business as they employ the largest percentage of our country. These business all spend a larger percentage of their revenue to make sure they are paying as little in taxes to the IRS by paying very expensive tax lawyers and accountants to find every deduction and exception possible. Not that I have anything against lawyers, I would rather employ 10 real workers and than 1 over paid , white-collar criminal (I mean lawyer). Having a federal sales tax would free up businesses from these oppressive opportunistic leeches. How much do I pay to government? Simple. 1% of all sales you made. Move the decimal point 2 places to the left and pay that amount. No more keeping track of depreciation, time spent traveling, mileage, etc.. etc.. etc.. Just think of how much money across our country that will be saved and freed up to spend on hiring more workers or purchase more goods. We can even start taxing internet businesses (why should they be exempt?) and bring in money from abroad as well (after all, we invented the Internet, shouldn't we reap its benefits as well?) Also, by not having to over-pay our workers to cover their taxes to the IRS, businesses can actually pay less for their workers and be more competitive with other countries.
Frees up everyday Americans to invest.
Ask your average American why (besides risk) they don't invest in the stock market and they answer will undoubtedly be "I don't need the extra stress of figuring out my taxes on April 15th!" I am not lying when I say this is MY biggest problem with investments. Unlike CD's, Money Markets where I get a simple 1099-INT at that end of the year, stocks and bonds require me to keep track of a lot more information than I care to. When did I buy? When did I sell? What price did I buy? What price did I sell? Was it a tax-exempt-bond? Also, I have to then pay quarterly taxes to insure that the government gets its money ASAP! UGH! Who needs it! It explains also the explosion in tax-shelters that have come about in recent years. IRS's, Roth-IRA"s, Education-IRA's, VUL's, 529's, 401K, 403B's etc. etc.. Just more accounts the government allows us to have, all of which were lobbied heavily by investment houses like Merryll-Lynch
With the 1% Fed Sales Tax, all this goes away over night. There is no need for it! Who cares if the government takes 1% of my earnings? If my investments earn a return of 10% before tax, then after tax they have still earned 9.99%. The taxes can also be collected by the investment houses themselves thereby simplifying our lives even more. No records to keep. No Tax accountants to pay.
Government can still use the tax to encourage societal change.
One concern people have with such a simple tax, that government will no longer have the ability to encourage society to be in ways they perceive as beneficial to all of us. Whether its the environment or giving to charities we see these as things we want to promote. But the sales tax can still be used by the government to encourage people in our country to act in certain ways. For example, if they want to encourage people to use electric vehicles, they can give that company a No-Sales-Tax exemption card that would allow them to sell their product with no sales tax. If congress wants to help the extreme poor or charities, they can still handout "rebates" or "exemption cards". They can also make sure that things like food and other necessities are not taxed just like the states do already. They can also "sin-tax" certain activities more such as smoking or maybe even certain kinds of non-productive investments such as "short-selling-stocks".
Fair to all
What angers me most about paying my taxes is know that somewhere out there, there is someone who is NOT paying their fair share. Either by using loop-holes or just plain not paying them. Who was not angered this past month as the President paraded appointment after appointment for White House positions that did not pay all of their taxes to the Feds. Had they not been nominated, they would have gotten away with 100's of thousands of dollars of fraud to the IRS. Do we really think the IRS is their reviewing every 1040 sent their way? Get real here! We all know they can only check a fraction of a percent our returns and many play the game of Catch-Me-If-You-Can. With the Fed Sales tax NO ONE GETS AWAY WITH ANYTHING. Buy a yacht? Pay the tax. Buy a new Mercedes? Pay the tax. Buy second home? Pay the tax. Make a killing on the stock market? Pay the tax. No exceptions! No rule breakers! No cheats!
Frees up our government to do what its supposed to do.... Govern!
Instead of spending weeks, months, years endlessly arguing over where to put the line of who is rich and who is not. Instead of wasting time re-writing outdated tax code to keep it "current", our lawmakers can spend their time with more important matters such as how to improve our schools, hospitals or inner-cities.
Free the Workers of America!
Can you imagine the psychological impact across our great country when the sales tax is initiated and the income-tax is removed? Can you imagine as people across the nation have 20,30,40% more in their bank accounts every week? It would have the same impact as the Emancipation Proclamation had on the slaves in the 1860's !!! Freed from the tirrany of their oppressors they would be enabled to live as truly free people. To spend, save, invest as THEY want and not as the GOVERNMENT wants!! It moves the government to the back of the line instead of the front of the line. It insures that our leaders don't get a penny more from us and our economy unless our economy is actually PRODUCING something (an issue I know drives most of our congressman no nothing about!).